Welcome to the PSP Maze — where what seems like a simple integration can silently cost you thousands.
For founders, backend engineers, and operators, choosing a Payment Service Provider (PSP) isn't just a box to check. The decision impacts your bottom line, customer experience, and even how fast you scale.
This article is your flashlight. We'll walk through how to choose the right PSP—not the most popular or cheapest, but the one that aligns with your business model, tech stack, and growth ambitions.
Not All PSPs Are Built the Same
Stripe. Adyen. Square. Braintree. PayPal. On the surface, they all do the same thing: process payments. But that's like saying all cars drive.
Under the hood, they're entirely different machines:
- Stripe and Checkout.com are built for developers. Their APIs are elegant, their docs are excellent, and you can ship fast.
- Adyen and Worldpay are built on a global scale. They give you control and direct access to card networks if you do serious volume across markets.
- Square, PayPal, and Clover cater to small businesses that want ease, hardware, and bundling.
So ask yourself: do you need developer speed, volume efficiency, or SMB simplicity? Your choice starts there.
Start With Your Business Model
Choosing the wrong PSP is like buying a sports car to deliver groceries. You need alignment.
- Running a subscription SaaS? Prioritize PSPs with native billing engines and dunning management.
- Selling internationally? Look for PSPs with local acquiring, multicurrency support, and low cross-border fees.
- Retail store going online? Omnichannel support will save you future headaches.
-
Luxury/high-ticket items? You'll want higher auth thresholds and fraud tools that don't block legitimate buyers.
If your model is evolving, pick a PSP that lets you grow into complexity — Braintree's tokenization or Adyen's unified commerce tools are great examples.
Technical Details That Can Cost You Later
Here's where things get sticky. Some of the most painful payment bugs happen because the PSP wasn't appropriately evaluated from a technical standpoint.
-
Do they support async flows and robust webhook retries?
-
Are the tokens portable, or will you get vendor lock-in?
-
Can you build routing rules by geography or BIN?
-
Do they give actionable decline codes or vague "Do Not Honor" messages?
Talk to their solutions engineer early. If a PSP doesn't support cascading or has noisy webhook retries, that's a red flag.
You Can Negotiate More Than You Think
Here's a secret: your payment fees are not set in stone.
Once your volume picks up, go back to the table. Ask for:
- Interchange+ pricing for transparency
- Volume-based tiered discounts
- Bundled discounts on fraud tools or chargeback services
Even Stripe, known for its take-it-or-leave-it pricing, will budge if your numbers justify it. Bring data. Bring competitors' quotes. Ask for more.
Conclusion
Without scrutiny, you wouldn't outsource your product, pricing strategy, or customer support. Payments should be no different. Pick a PSP like you're hiring a partner, because that's what they are. They touch every dollar that flows into your business.
And when you choose wisely? Higher auth rates. Lower fees. Fewer angry customers. More revenue.